Categories and comparisons. Douglas Adams meets Dostoyevsky?!?

That would be an extremely odd book, but from what I read on agent blogs, such unusual pairings are not unheard of in query letters. Some agents want you to tell them who your book is like, comparing it to other authors so that they’ll have a ready comparison from the marketing divisions of publishing houses.

However, also based on what I’ve read, such comparisons can shoot you in the foot. I compared my urban fantasy to Terry Pratchett meets Charles de Lint. It STILL makes sense to me, but I think I’m the only one. I ultimately removed that from my query letter since I clearly don’t get the comparison game. I’m just sticking with “urban fantasy” even though my writing group has suggested other writers to compare myself to, but I’ve never read those authors, and I can’t see comparing my writing to an author I’ve never read. Now, that’s an interesting question. Have you ever read a book simply to use the comparison to it in your cover letter? ^_^

What about the rest of you? Do you use comparisons at all? Only if a particular agent asks? My very favorite query letter request was from an agent who wanted to know which author my story was like and also how it was different. I think she’s who I wrote the Pratchett/de Lint match-up for. Dark urban fantasy meets humor, the difference being more of an emphasis on a romantic subplot. See? That still only makes sense to me.

8 thoughts on “Categories and comparisons. Douglas Adams meets Dostoyevsky?!?

  1. I assuming you are talking about “Signal” – and actually I think dark urban fantasy meets humor and a strong romantic sub-plot describes it quite precisely?! I understand that comparing to other authors is bunk, but I think placing it within genre still makes sense.

  2. Barbara,

    I have only done so for one manuscript (as a pitch), yet have never included it in a cover letter. I think it is such a risky proposition and feels kind of braggy. Like, Look at me, I write like XYZ. And, like you said, what if you’re the only one who gets it?

    Or maybe I’m just too chicken…

  3. I feel that comparing oneself to another author will just as likely backfire. More often than not it will be seen as simply pretentious.
    As Ross said above it is well worth placing yourself in a genre.

  4. I agree with you that unless you “have” to give a comparision, it’s not usually helpful in a letter. With your verbal explanation, it might be, in the same way that that talking about the writers and works you love gives an idea of your sensibilities.

    And I wonder if comparisions of your work to other works by (ahem) well-meaning fans is the same thing that happens when a friend says, “Oh you’ve got to meet so-and-so. You have so much in common, you’ll just love her”…but you never do (or, at least, I never do).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s